Meh. His hot-to-crazy ratio is skewed the wrong way. The only movie I really like him in is 'Reign of Fire,' and that's really only because he's in it with Christian Bale and Gerard Butler.
Back when he was unknown, and his first big movie, A Time To Kill, was about to be released, I saw a photo of him in a brochure put out by our local (Oxford, England) movie theatre. He was so *perfect* that I used him as the model/inspiration for Lord Graeth, the hero of my then-work in process, THE WILD ONE. I still think of Gareth every time I see Matthew McC!-- Danelle Harmon, author
He does absolutely nothing for me, I mean I am kind of repulsed by him..so weird
This is another example of a guy who doesn't do much for me unless I see him in a certain light. Meaning, he totally does it for me in The Wedding Planner, and yes, he is very pretty (without the beard) but there is just something about him in that movie...nice.